Reviews

Sunday, 23 September 2012 17:17

To Have and to Hold by Philipp Blom Featured

Written by
Rate this item
(0 votes)

To Have and to Hold
By Philipp Blom
Paperback: 345 pages
Publisher: Overlook TP (May 25, 2004)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 158567561X
ISBN-13: 978-1585675616

In a nutshell, reading Philipp Blom’s book is time well spent. At first, the sight of beetles and insects on its cover is not only disconcerting but also not at all appetising.
 
However the full title of the book, To Have and To Hold: An Intimate History of Collectors and Collecting, takes the reader into the private world of people whose lives are so connected with the idea of collecting stuff that you’re instantly hooked.
 
Start flicking through the pages and you need not go far before you encounter the first of many things that makes the book unique. The titles Blom gives his chapters are in themselves interesting, for example, ‘Parliament of Monsters’, ‘An Ark Abducted’ and ‘Why Boling People is Wrong’.
 
The order in which her presents the chapters is cleverly structured to reveal the routes collectors take to explore their interest.
 
We begin with Blom’s story about the three gentlemen he knew who had started him thinking about collectors and collecting. One of them collects books because he did not have much or a formal education in his youth. Now, he makes up for that by collecting and reading every book he can get his hands on.
 
Then, we are taken on a historical journey which involves the collection of mystical items and relics from a bygone ear. Next, there are strange plants, animals and insects to consider. Once nature has been ‘conquered’, we learnt about the collection of things human – organs, skulls and ‘unnatural’ people.  
 
We turn next to what I like to call the hybrid between relics and humans – memorabilia of and from people who have become relics themselves. An example of this would be Napoleon Bonaparte’s locks.
 
The book comes a full circle when Blom relates the story of another man who collects an enormous amount of books, manuscripts and anything at all in print.
 
It is obvious that lots of research has gone into this book. Moreover, what is astounding is the manner in which Blom has conveyed the intimate details of the collectors’ lives, their problems, misfortunes, fortunes and idiosyncrasies and the era in which they live. He does it with such flair that the reader is bound to view this subject in new light. The language is simple and the message is conveyed effectively.
 
It is to Blom’s credit that he is able to foresee the questions a reader may have and has inserted his answers where appropriate. For example, by the time one is more that halfway thought the book, one begins to ask, “Why on earth would someone collect deformed babies who were born dead or died soon after birth?” Blom answers by saying that the value of these collections lie in their usefulness, significance, meaning and association with the collector.
 
The reader will no doubt go through a gamut of emotions reading this book. How, indeed, is it not possible to laugh when reading this:

‘… On leaving the Archangel the English party fired a salute with their ship’s cannon, thanking their hosts for the hospitality they had received. One of the cannons was unfortunately loaded and ripped a large hole in a harbourside house, leaving the hosts ‘gaping and in great perplexity’.’

In a chapter entitled The Exquisite Art of Dr. Ruysch, one cannot help but wonder how morbid a man the artist must be when his artwork, though beautiful, is made of things like a four-month-old foetus, minute kidney stones and intestines. There is also a demonstration of human cruelty when Blom writes about the eccentricity of one collector, Tsar Peter the Great:

‘Peter was a voracious collector of … natural oddities and freaks. His love of dwarfs and other freaks occasionally found expression in lavish and cruel festivities such as the marriage of the Royal Dwarf, Iakim Volkov, for which the tsar ordered dwarfs to be rounded up in Moscow and sent to St. Petersburg where they were shut up like cattle for several days and then received especially tailored clothes in which they had to celebrate Volkov’s wedding as one large assembly of Lilliputians, while normal sized onlookers did little to stifle their laughter …’

The illustrations in this book are clear and well-placed. Alas, there are no captions under any of these illustrations and at times, having to constantly refer to the beginning of the book for the title of a painting or sculpture and its origins can be most irksome.
 
All said and done, towards the end of the book, one realises that this is a serious study and Blom sums up by referring to the earlier-mentioned enormous collection of books and manuscripts: ‘The sheer accumulation of books does not constitute a library. It is also their organisation, the ordering mind inhabiting and ruling them.’
 
Finally, he suggest that perhaps it is not wise to hold on to things. Still, this is one book I would not only like to read again, I will certainly hold on to it.
 
7 March 2008
 
[A similar review of this book was written and published in the local newspaper, The Star, in April 2004.]

Read 78 times Last modified on Sunday, 14 November 2021 18:43

Comments powered by CComment

Latest Posts

  • The Creative Industry Needs to Look at Things Differently Post Budget 2022
    On 29 October 2021, the Finance Minister, Datuk Seri Tengku Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz tabled Budget 2022 in the Malaysian parliament. RM50 million has been allocated for the arts and culture industry. This comes after a year and a half after the entire industry came to an absolute standstill. With…
  • ‘The Covid Positives’ – life lessons learnt from the pandemic by Phanindra Ivatury
    After a long drawn battle with the biggest catastrophe in our living memory, global humanity is finally getting to see some quintessential ray of light at the end of the treacherous tunnel in the form of COVID-19 vaccines, currently being rolled out to all parts of the globe. A ‘COVID-19…
  • Chaos of Whole Books
    Is it possible to read several books at once? Aneeta Sundararaj finds out. When I was a child, my cousin used to boast that he could read four storybooks at a time. As an adult, when he invested in an e-Reader, he continued to boast that he could…
  • Writing for You? Or for Me?
    Writing for You? Or for Me? ‘You must always write with your reader in mind.’ This was one of the first pieces of advice that I received when I began my writing career. Honestly, I found this extremely hard to do because more often than not, I couldn’t picture my…
  • One Book That Changed My Writing Life
    My latest novel, The Age of Smiling Secrets was shortlisted for two categories in the Book Award 2020 organised by the National Library of Malaysia. When I reflected on the journey that this book has taken, I acknowledged the enormous influence of one of my all-time favourite books, Joseph Anton:…